Athletes train for performance. Why don’t leaders?

From the Boat Race to the boardroom: preparation, belief and recovery for people carrying consequential decisions.

Before the evidence

On 26 September I went back to Cambridge for a boat club reunion. It brought me back to the question that links rowing with the work I do now: how do we prepare people to perform?

In 1999 I rowed for Cambridge in the Boat Race. We were the underdogs, with no returning Blues. We built belief, beat Oxford and won in record time.

It is a pleasing story to open an article about leadership. The trouble is that once you have won, the story starts to sound inevitable. The underdogs become a promising crew. The belief looks justified. Everyone can see how the ending was reached, because they already know it.

We did not have that luxury beforehand.

That is the part that interests me now: how people prepare to do something difficult before there is any evidence they can do it, and what we can reasonably expect of them along the way.

I later became Partner and Co-CEO of an emerging markets investment firm, helping grow it to USD 5.5bn and leading 54 people across six offices. The comparison between rowing and running a business has limits. A board meeting does not end when somebody crosses a line, although occasionally it would help if it did.

But one difference keeps bothering me. In sport, preparation is understood to be part of performance. In leadership, we are quite capable of treating it as an interruption.

The meeting is in the diary. The time to think before it is negotiable.

The peculiar business of being ready

An athlete can spend most of a week preparing for a few minutes of competition. There is practice, feedback and some thought about whether the person doing the work is fit to do it again.

A leader’s diary makes a different proposition. Here are eight back-to-back conversations. Please bring clarity, patience, commercial judgement and the ability to listen to each one. Lunch is at your discretion.

I understand the appeal of that diary. It looks useful. People need you. Things are happening. There is plenty of evidence that you have worked.

It says much less about how well you have thought.

A consequential conversation may need you to notice something you would rather avoid. An investment decision may require you to tell conviction from attachment. A colleague may need enough of your attention to finish a thought without you supplying the answer.

These demands are easy to underestimate because they do not look strenuous from the outside. You are mostly sitting down.

Belief needs somewhere to come from

Our crew built belief. I want to be careful with that phrase, because it can sound as though we agreed to be optimistic and the boat obliged.

The more useful question is what makes belief credible. What have we done that lets us trust ourselves and each other? Where do we still need work? What can we honestly say about our chances without pretending to know the outcome?

I have carried versions of those questions into investment committees and leadership teams ever since. Confidence is useful. So is being able to explain what it rests on.

People also need room to admit uncertainty. It is hard to improve something everyone has agreed to call excellent.

Who is looking after the next performance?

The athlete comparison is most useful to me when it brings recovery into the conversation.

At work, recovery can sound slightly apologetic, as though it is something you ask for after failing to manage your workload. Yet the next decision will still need a functioning person to make it.

Founders, partners and CEOs often care deeply about their people and their businesses. That care can make it harder to stop. There is always another person to call, another problem to absorb, another piece of preparation you could have done.

I have sympathy for that. Responsibility is not easily put away at six o’clock.

But we need ways of carrying it that leave us able to keep doing the work well. Making space to think, asking for help and taking recovery seriously all belong in that discussion. Their value lies in the performance they support, and in the lives of the people doing the performing.

What I want to explore

This is what I will be writing about from here: sustained performance. Making consequential decisions, leading through others, and developing as the demands of the job change.

My experience gives me plenty to draw on and plenty to question. I want to look at what we practise, how we prepare and what helps us recover, honestly enough to include the times when knowing better has not meant doing better.

The Boat Race has a finish. Leadership tends to come with another Tuesday.

How are you preparing for yours?

Read the original on Substack →

Continue reading

Continue reading On Judgement →

Back to Thinking

Next
Next

We’re doomed?